attack provinces Taleban tech War & Peace

Five Days in August Five Days in August (2): The situation after the Taleban attack on Ghazni (2): The situation after the Taleban attack on Ghazni

One of the three civilian cars that were destroyed in a night raid on 30 November 2018 in Alizai village of Andar district. Photo: Author/2018

One in every of three civilian automobiles that locals stated have been destroyed in an evening raid on 30 November 2018 in Alizai village of Andar district. Photograph: Writer/2018

The Taleban might have been pushed again out of Ghazni metropolis after their five-day siege in August, however they’ve continued to broaden into new territory across the metropolis. They now have full management of eight districts in Ghazni province. They management the Ghazni-Paktika freeway and proceed to place strain on the Kabul-Kandahar freeway. On this, the second of a two-part collection, AAN’s Fazal Muzhary, who visited Ghazni earlier than the August assault and a number of other occasions since (and with enter from Ali Yawar Adili), finds the town nonetheless weak to a different Taleban assault. An upsurge in night time raids and airstrikes has restricted Taleban motion, but in addition triggered civilian casualties and impelled some individuals to go away their villages. As but, these have had no influence on the Taleban’s management of territory on this strategic province.

The primary half on this mini-series, “Unheeded Warnings (1): Wanting again on the Taleban assault on Ghazni” might be learn right here. 

Growing Taleban management of the districts

Ranges of hysteria among the many inhabitants of Ghazni metropolis that the Taleban will assault once more has not diminished within the 4 months because the insurgents’ onslaught in August. Individuals from numerous neighbourhoods, akin to Bazazi, the Kandahar bus stand, Gudali, Pashtunabad, Qala-ye Jawz, Rauza and the Ali Lala Saheb all described to AAN how that they had misplaced confidence of their authorities’s potential to guard them. They’ve seen that the federal government has redeployed Afghan Nationwide Police (ANP) to solely a few of the safety posts on the outskirts of the town that have been taken over or destroyed by the Taleban in August 2018. In the meantime, they’ve additionally watched with dread because the Taleban have expanded their management over a number of extra districts within the province, together with ones near the town.

Residents’ views are shared by elected representatives and officers from the province. MP Abdul Qayum Sajjadi, for instance, warned of a potential second fall of Ghazni in a press release that he shared on Fb on 15 October 2018. He urged President Ashraf Ghani to order an anti-Taleban clearing operation within the province (see his remarks right here in Dari).

Talking on the ceremony to introduce a brand new provincial police chief on 23 October, governor Wahidullah Kalimzai raised his considerations that the warfare “was nonetheless intensifying, the safety forces stepping again and the Taleban are tightening their siege of Ghazni metropolis” (extra about this under).

Based on provincial council member Abdul Bari Shelgarai (quoted right here), in September the Taleban had full management of six of Ghazni’s 19 districts – Deh Yak, Khwaja Omari, Ajristan, Jaghatu, Jaghatu and Khogyani– in addition to the central district, except Ghazni metropolis itself (see Ghazni’s profile right here right here),

The governor’s spokesman, Aref Nuri (quoted in the identical information report), performed down the state of affairs and claimed the Taleban managed solely three districts, specifically Khwaja Omari, Ajristan and Nawa. Nevertheless, Nuri admitted to AAN that the federal government thought-about districts to be underneath authorities management if authorities safety forces have been current someplace within the district, even when their presence was restricted to just a few safety posts. He insisted the federal government had the power to retake these three districts, however there have been “not sufficient forces” to guard territory as soon as they have been recaptured.

On 20 September, the Taleban claimed that they had captured one other district within the province, Abband, on the primary Kabul-Kandahar freeway about 76 kilometres south of Ghazni metropolis. Shelgarai informed AAN the district had not fallen to the Taleban and that the police have been capable of maintain the attackers again. He added, nevertheless, that the Taleban remained in command of most areas of the district.

By early November, the variety of districts undoubtedly in Taleban arms, ie with the insurgents controlling the district centre and no authorities officers current, had elevated additional – to eight. The Taleban took full management of Andar (aside from two army bases) on 15 October and Khugyani on 5 November (see this Pajhwok report, and different reviews right here and right here).  On the day Andar fell, the Afghan Nationwide Police (ANP) unit stationed within the district compound deserted their place and moved to a close-by army base within the Chahrdiwal space. The ANA additionally has management over one other army base in Senai village of the district. The ANA are at present holding a purely defensive place in each. Even so, in a telephone interview with AAN, Nuri insisted the federal government nonetheless managed Andar, despite the fact that, because the writer has witnessed, Taleban fighters at the moment are within the district compound, which had been managed by authorities forces in late October 2018. (Extra element on the state of affairs in Andar may be discovered under.)

Elsewhere in Ghazni province, the insurgents attacked the district centres of Jaghori and Malestan in late October 2018 and got here near capturing each on 7 and 10 November. The assaults set off mass displacement and fears that the Taleban may even push additional north into the Hazara-inhabited districts of Maidan-Wardak province (extra element in these AAN analyses, right here and right here).

The Taleban have since been repelled from each districts, however they proceed to regulate main transport routes by means of Qarabagh, Nawur and Gilan districts. Though most faculties within the two districts, which had closed following the Taleban assault, have now reopened for this yr’s remaining exams, some stay closed, particularly in areas of Jaghori bordering Gilan and Muqur in Ghazni and Khak-e Afghan in Zabul provinces. IDPs have been reluctant to return to those locations after the Taleban blocked roads resulting in the 2 border districts on 9 December (right here).

On 18 November, the Ministry of Inside introduced it [sic] would set up two territorial military corporations (tolai) and mobilise 600 locals inside the framework of public rebellion forces within the Jaghori and Malestan, to take care of safety of their areas. The Territorial Military is a brand new native defence drive beneath the command of the Ministry of Defence, whereas rebellion forces are supposedly spontaneous rebellions organised by locals towards the insurgency, usually funded and sometimes organised by the Nationwide Directorate of Safety (NDS). Neither fall beneath the Ministry of Inside’s remit. Native sources, together with a district safety official who requested to not be named, informed AAN that the Taleban had ordered native individuals in Jaghori to ask the brand new authorities safety forces dispatched to the world after the assault to go away the district. That they had additionally ordered the individuals to not permit the formation of rebellion forces or territorial military models of their district.

The state of affairs in Ghazni metropolis

As for the provincial capital, the Taleban are sustaining a substantial presence in lots of areas alongside the outskirts of the town. AAN spoke to a number of native residents together with a driver, Esmatullah, who stated he and different locals had seen Taleban within the Qala-ye Mirai space, not more than three kilometres south of Ghazni’s police headquarters. Different residents, reminiscent of drivers and labourers dwelling on this space, confirmed the presence of Taleban fighters there. A businessman within the metropolis, Naqeb, informed the writer the Taleban had free motion within the Gudali space, about three kilometres to the northwest of the police headquarters. When President Ghani made a second journey to Ghazni metropolis on 27 September, the Taleban used these positions, notably within the Jangalbagh space, a bit additional out, about 5 kilometres to the northwest of the town, to fireside rockets into Ghazni to disrupt his go to. On 21 November, the writer witnessed the Taleban rocketing the town once more, when Common Scott Miller, commander of NATO and United States forces, visited (media report right here). One of many rockets hit a personal well being clinic about 300 metres from the writer’s personal residence, within the centre of the town. Fortunately, there have been no casualties.

The Taleban’s ban on phone corporations working between seven and ten o’ clock within the morning, already in place between four and 20 September, additional stoked public considerations. Though the Taleban haven’t truly lifted this ban, telephone corporations presently solely function intermittently. Authorities officers principally talk with the assistance of the state-run Salaam community. Different networks solely cowl the town and restricted areas alongside its outskirts; typically conversations are minimize off.

Extra element on Andar district, now underneath full Taleban management

Andar is likely one of the districts on the fringes of Ghazni metropolis’s suburbs. Its centre, Mirai, is merely a 30-minute drive away. For Andar’s inhabitants, the district’s takeover by the Taleban on 15 October truly normalised public providers. Full management by one aspect has proved a greater state of affairs for civilians than their district being contested. Every week after Afghan safety forces deserted the district centre, the city reopened. Outlets that had beforehand needed to shut due to the preventing, because the Taleban tightened their grip on the district compound, the ANP forces’ final bastion, in Might 2018 (see AAN’s earlier dispatch right here),are once more open; it’s ‘enterprise as regular’.

The Taleban gave permission for the Sultan Shahabuddin Excessive Faculty to maneuver again into its previous constructing within the district centre on 25 October; it needed to depart its premises there in 2006 when Taleban assaults intensified that yr. Schooling officers had relocated the varsity to Narmi, a Taleban-controlled village the place it continued to function in a main faculty constructing. The varsity was managed by the Taleban, however funded by the federal government. Andar district hospital additionally relocated again to the district centre on 25 October; it had been moved to the Zakuri space within the spring of 2018, when the Taleban elevated their grip on the district city. The relocation of each hospital and highschool to the district centre got here as a aid to native residents. One instructor, Atiqullah, advised AAN “The first faculty constructing was very small for housing two faculties. Subsequently, a lot of the college students would attend courses in an open area, which was a hassle each for academics and college students.” The constructing in Zakuri, the place the hospital had been briefly moved to, had initially been demarcated as a primary well being centre, which was additionally already in operation earlier than the hospital moved there. Each docs and sufferers have been struggling on account of a scarcity of correct amenities and area.

There can be extra element on this in a forthcoming dispatch in our ‘Service Supply in Rebel-Affected Areas’ collection: see the primary two dispatches right here ( and right here (

Andar district has been stricken by again and forths in authorities and Taleban management of the final two years. The final time the Taleban had management of Andar district centre they closed the district centre together with a lot of the companies within the bazaar. This was forward of the 2010 parliamentary election, however the district centre was solely reopened in 2012 after a gaggle of individuals, primarily from inside Taleban ranks, rose up towards the Taleban: this was when the time period wulusi patsun (‘widespread‘ or ’individuals’s rebellion’) was coined (see AAN evaluation right here, right here and right here).

Throughout these years, the district centre remained principally accessible to civilians, and intermittently to the federal government, ie it was not in Taleban arms, however officers additionally couldn’t essentially get in or out, at the very least by street and in security. Over the 2014 presidential election interval, the federal government made efforts to safe the district centre, however since then, it has wavered between being accessible and inaccessible, till 15 October 2018 when it got here, as soon as once more, into Taleban palms.

Three weeks after the Taleban took full management over Andar, on four November 2018, they set very strict controls on polio vaccinations. They informed well being officers they might solely vaccinate youngsters in village mosques explaining this was due to safety threats and assaults to their fighters and to minimise operations towards them. Native residents informed AAN the Taleban thought the vaccinators have been amassing intelligence knowledge. The upshot is that vaccinators can’t go from home to deal with, as they often do. That is vital: going house-to-house is much better for youngsters and the one means to make sure protection is close to sufficient full. Ghazni’s public well being division head, Zahir Shah Nekmal, warned in an interview with Azadi Radio, that underneath these circumstances, they might cease your complete three-month vaccination effort till the Taleban modified a coverage that he considers quantities to a ban. The Taleban haven’t given in, nevertheless, and, for now, Andars’ youngsters will not be being vaccinated (see media report right here).

Primary roads minimize off by the Taleban

Since they attacked Ghazni metropolis, the Taleban have additionally been blocking key roads. The street to neighbouring Paktika province was already minimize off earlier than the Taleban assault on Ghazni metropolis and the takeover of Andar district centre, and stays closed each to authorities and civilian automobiles and vans. It runs previous the ANA base at Chahardiwal which does stay in authorities arms. On 29 September, Taleban fighters ploughed up sections of the freeway in numerous villages, similar to Khani Qala, Zur Shahr, Chahardiwal, Urzu, Alamwal and Rahimkhel, to stop authorities reinforcements being despatched both from Ghazni metropolis or by way of Paktika province, or from Paktia additional east, the place the military’s regional corps headquarters is predicated. In consequence, civilians has additionally been hampered from utilizing this route.

As an alternative, since Might 2018, they’ve had to make use of various routes via villages within the district which are beneath agency Taleban management (see AAN’s earlier dispatch for particulars right here).  On a type of routes, close to Jani Qala, the Taleban established a income assortment check-point in early Might, the place they cost virtually each truck that passes via.

Of much more concern to native individuals is the closure to visitors of the Kabul-Kandahar freeway, aka Freeway One. On 6 October, the Taleban spokesman introduced that they had closed the freeway to their ‘enemies’ and that, because of attainable bombardments and preventing and the potential for civilian casualties, bus drivers shouldn’t use the street till additional discover (see Pajhwok report (see Pajhwok report). After a couple of days, the Taleban allowed civilian automobiles by way of once more, however – as in Andar – arrange a checkpoint for income assortment within the Mushaki space in Qarabagh district about 50 kilometres to the south of Ghazni metropolis. In line with native sources conscious of the Taleban’s plan for this space, this blockade, appears to be everlasting, aimed toward boosting the insurgents’ income assortment and interrupting ANSF automobiles alongside this main nationwide freeway. Residents informed AAN that, as of early December, the Taleban have been hiring civilian tractors and bulldozers to work on levelling an alternate route, an previous street that passes close to Nur ul-Madares, the well-known seminary in Andar district close to Mastaufi village, by means of western elements of Andar district. As soon as the street is levelled, Freeway 1 visitors might be diverted by means of this 50 kilometre lengthy stretch; the general public is properly conscious of this plan – see this Fb publish, for instance).

Modifications within the provincial administration

On the federal government aspect, Ghazni police chief Farid Mashal, whose forces led the one vital resistance towards the Taleban through the assault, was changed on 13 October. When requested for the rationale, the governor’s spokesman, Aref Nuri, informed AAN that Mashal’s safety personnel had been misusing energy and violating the regulation. He stated Ghazni’s residents had gone to President Ghani and, based mostly on these complaints, he changed Mashal and his workforce. In response to Nuri, a lot of the complaints have been about “extorting cash from drivers and being concerned in immoral actions by harassing kids.” Furthermore, a number of sources advised AAN these policemen have been “sexually harassing kids.” Nuri stated that not one of many policemen had been arrested as a result of there was no proof or complaints about particular instances that might be registered. Moreover, based on this media report (see right here), native residents advised Shamshad TV that safety personnel would “arrest boys and sexually assault them.” One native journalist, confirming such misbehaviour, advised AAN that the police chief had additionally proved ineffective in controlling the state of affairs throughout his three-month probationary interval, as a result of the state of affairs had worsened and this was the rationale why he was changed. The governor’s spokesman additionally confirmed this as one more reason behind his alternative.

Mashal was changed by Ghulam Daud Tarakhel, who beforehand labored as commander of the 505 police zone within the southern province of Helmand. Aref Nuri advised AAN that Daud had acquired police and army coaching each on the police academy in Kabul and overseas, and had army expertise. In his introductory speech, Tarakhel responded to governor Kalimzai’s considerations, saying he knew Ghazni very properly and would attempt to take steps to enhance safety within the province. Nevertheless, the one change seen to date has been the redeployment of ANP forces to a number of the safety posts destroyed by the Taleban in the course of the August assault. These redeployments haven’t modified the state of affairs as they weren’t adopted by any operation to dislodge the Taleban from Ghazni metropolis’s outskirts.

Airstrikes, civilian casualties & new modifications

Because the Taleban have been repulsed from Ghazni – or determined to go away the town (which, isn’t clear, see half 1 of this mini-series right here), there was a rise in night time raids and airstrikes by Afghan and US forces in most districts of the province, in response to totally different districts’ residents the writer spoke with, in addition to witnessed by the writer personally in Andar and Deh Yak districts. The joint nature of the night time raids was additionally confirmed by the governor’s spokesman. It appears they’re principally carried out by Afghan commandos, with US army current (see media reviews right here: (see media stories right here, right here, right here, and right here), As for the airstrikes, residents reported Afghan helicopters have been firing rockets, however not bombing, which they stated was being carried out by the US air drive. It’s truly extraordinarily troublesome to inform from the bottom what plane is releasing bombs, whether or not Afghan or US, and whether or not aircraft or drone.

Residents have additionally reported that, whereas some Taleban fighters have been killed within the strikes, they haven’t suffered main casualties. Furthermore, these airstrikes and raids have proved ineffective in dislodging Taleban fighters from areas they management, even these near the town. For instance, the Taleban might nonetheless assault the newly arrange ANP publish within the Spandeh space on 22 November, an assault the writer himself witnessed. One other instance was the 27 November roadside bombing of American troopers within the Shahbaz space, which had been beneath authorities management earlier than the August assault. On this assault, three American troopers have been killed and one other three, together with a contractor, have been wounded (media report right here). The Taleban instantly took duty for the blast and claimed in a press release that the convoy had been on its strategy to an operation (see footage of the destroyed army car).

The roadside bombing additionally proved that US troops are actively supporting the Afghan forces in Ghazni now. In line with Aref Nuri, the US troopers have been based mostly in Ghazni since mid-November 2018. He gave no particulars about their numbers or whether or not they have been particular or common forces.

The elevated numbers of night time raids and airstrikes have definitely led to casualties amongst each militants and civilians. Nevertheless, the size of the casualties and who’s being killed is disputed. AAN has been making an attempt to get a way of the casualties by evaluating Afghan official sources, which are likely to exaggerate rebel deaths and downplay or deny any hurt finished to civilians, Taleban sources, which do the other, and native civilians.

The Afghan authorities and native officers claimed their operations have resulted in numerous casualties among the many insurgents. Chatting with AAN on 16 December, the governor’s spokesman stated that as many as 36 airstrikes and floor operations had been carried out since mid-November 2018 in several districts of the province. Consequently, he stated 146 militants had been killed and 90 wounded. Furthermore, he stated the deaths had included 43 Pakistanis, 40 of whom have been killed in Nawa and Gilan districts and three in Qarabagh. AAN seemed via the statements revealed on Fb by the governor’s workplace in November ; in complete, they listed 248 militants as having been killed and one other 59 wounded.

The writer spoke by telephone and face-to-face with a number of residents from Gilan and acquired an inventory of seven named civilians whom residents stated have been killed and 14 others whom they stated have been wounded in airstrikes and shelling by Afghan safety forces based mostly in neighbouring Jaghori district (1). AAN additionally spoke to individuals in Muqur, Deh Yak, Andar, Waghaz, Qarabagh and Khogyani districts. The numbers of Taleban casualties given by residents didn’t  add as much as these given by the governor’s spokesman, however they did affirm a few of them. Virtually all stated the night time raids and airstrikes had additionally brought about civilian casualties and destruction to civilian property, which, they stated, had not been reported by officers. In a single incident on 30 October, in response to AAN’s sources, seven madrasa college students have been killed and their instructor, Mullah Ehsanullah, was wounded, throughout an evening raid on their seminary in Sarbeland Qala village in Waghaz district. Native residents who visited the world stated no Taleban fighters had been there. Nevertheless, the governor’s workplace, as soon as once more on its Fb web page, posted a press release through which officers claimed that 17 insurgents, together with two commanders, had been killed on this joint Afghan-US raid. The assertion stated that no civilians had been killed.

In neighbouring Andar district, overseas troopers, accompanied by the 01 unit of Afghan Nationwide Military’s commandos, raided Alizai village and the Nur ul-Madares madrasa on 30 November. A 44-year previous villager named Naser was killed within the raid. Family members of the sufferer advised AAN the joint forces took him from the room the place he was sitting with different relations to an empty room, from the place the relations heard a couple of photographs. When the raid was over, the relations discovered his lifeless physique in that room. Nazer was a farmer, however, since spring 2018, had additionally been working as an observer on the polio vaccination marketing campaign. He’s survived by his spouse, who’s pregnant, 5 daughters and 4 sons. 4 different individuals have been arrested, together with a prepare dinner, a madrasa guard and two different villagers. Moreover, the troopers burned three civilian automobiles, considered one of them belonging to an area physician, Najibullah (see photographs of his automotive right here). Elders from Andar went to Ghazni to complain and met governor Kalimzai, who informed them he was unaware of the arrests, however stated civilians can be launched if confirmed harmless (see the governor’s assertion and photographs of the assembly right here).

One other night time raid was reported in Tasang village in Deh Yak district on 1 December. Locals advised AAN that about 15 Taleban fighters had been killed. For as soon as, the numbers nearly tallied with the federal government’s; it stated as many as 16 Taleban fighters had been killed within the raid, which additionally focused Daulat Khan village (see right here). In the meantime, the Taleban claimed in a press release that their fighters have been conscious of the raid and had ambushed the joint forces, because of which three American troopers and 7 Afghan commandos had been killed (see their assertion right here). Native residents additionally informed AAN that airstrikes after the raid had demolished six civilian homes and 4 mosques.

Residents in Wali Qala and Kadai villages in Khogyani district advised AAN that two civilians and three Taleban fighters had been killed when Afghan Nationwide Military (ANA) troopers raided a home on 5 December. They despatched a delegation to Ghazni metropolis and met governor Kalimzai, who promised he was going to personally probe the incident and would share his findings with them (see his assertion right here).

A newer night time raid occurred in Sulemanzi village of Deh Yak district, the place, in response to one media report, three civilians have been killed and one other 4 arrested. Nevertheless, locals within the space advised AAN that two Taleban had been killed and 4 civilians arrested. They stated the Afghan and US forces additionally destroyed a personal clinic, a home and three mosques.

Because of these operations, each civilians and the Taleban have modified their behaviour. For instance, in a lot of the villages the place Taleban fighters are visibly current and might be targets of airstrikes or night time raids, individuals are leaving their homes at night time and staying in close by villages. Based mostly on interviews with residents and website visits by this writer, it can be reported that the Taleban have significantly decreased their actions in areas the place that they had beforehand been seen. In response to residents, the native Taleban management has informed their fighters to not transfer with weapons in areas the place they could possibly be targets of night time raids and airstrikes. Furthermore, in some areas, when Taleban are on the transfer, they don’t journey in teams bigger than two or three individuals. Earlier than the rise in airstrikes, each native respondents and the writer had witnessed the Taleban shifting in bigger teams.


Whereas the Taleban didn’t maintain maintain of Ghazni metropolis after their August assault, their positions outdoors – together with even in a number of the suburbs – haven’t been put beneath any strain by authorities forces. The Taleban have additionally taken full management of six districts since August and now absolutely management eight districts, apart from a really restricted authorities presence in a number of safety posts. As well as, 5 different districts are extremely contested. These are Aabband, Giro, Gelan, Qarabagh, Waghaz, and Zana Khan. In these districts the federal government maintains a presence within the district compound and some different areas, whereas the agricultural areas are beneath Taleban management. After the deployment of US troopers to Ghazni in mid-November, there was an upsurge in airstrikes and night time raids which have restricted the Taleban’s potential to maneuver, however not modified the general stability of energy. The districts of Jaghori and Malestan, following the assault on them in October and November, are calmer however nonetheless removed from protected.

The primary loss in all that is, in fact, the individuals killed and injured and people displaced from their houses. Nevertheless, the struggle in Ghazni and the Taleban’s management of a lot of the province have political implications too. With no main and sustainable authorities troop offensive, it’s troublesome to see how the parliamentary elections, delayed in September (see AAN background right here and right here), will have the ability to go forward, nor the presidential election, aside from within the provincial capital and a few district centres. Each are as a consequence of be held  on 20 April 2019.  To carry a extra substantial and consultant election in Ghazni province the federal government must retake eight districts and take away the Taleban from contested areas earlier than April; certainly, it must do that a lot sooner if preparations and campaigning within the province have been to occur. Voter registration was not carried out in Ghazni’s districts, and even in Ghazni metropolis, it was incomplete. For the second at the very least, it’s troublesome to see any kind of significant election happening on this embattled province.


Edited by Thomas Ruttig, Sari Kouvo and Kate Clark


(1) The record AAN acquired consists of the next civilians killed in Gilan district alone since early November 2018, notably within the Rasana space.


  1. Shahzadi, spouse of Nazar Muhammad.
  2. Bakht Bibi, spouse of Abdul Malik
  3. Spouse of Muhibullah
  4. Muhammad Khair
  5. Zmarai, son of Khudaidad
  6. Saat Maluk, son of Nazar Muhammad
  7. Abdul Samad, son of Ghulam Muhammad


  1. Razia, daughter of Abdul Malik
  2. Kamela, daughter of Abdul Malik
  3. Rahmat Bibi, daughter of Abdul Malik
  4. Muhammad, son of Abdul Malik
  5. Abdul Waris, son of Abdul Hanan
  6. Abdul Sadiq, son of Ghausuddin
  7. Nabiullah, son of Khudaidad
  8. Sharifa, daughter of Muhammad Khalil
  9. Mirwais, son of Habibullah
  10. Rahimdad, son of Mangal
  11. Alaf Khan, son of Daulat Khan
  12. Abdul Hanan, son of Abdul Ghaias
  13. Nur Khan, son of Jankhan
  14. Haji Taleb



Tagged with: assault, provinces, Taleban
Thematic Class: Struggle & Peace